Chest vs Upright Freezer: Which Is Right for Your Home?

Kogan 204L upright frost free freezer in white

A second freezer is a game changer for big families, bulk shoppers, home cooks who batch-cook, and anyone who catches fish or buys meat in bulk. The first decision is the shape. This chest vs upright freezer comparison explains the strengths of each so you can choose the right one for your space and habits.

Chest vs upright at a glance

Chest freezer Upright freezer
Shape Wide, low, lid opens from the top Tall and narrow, door opens from the front
Floor space Takes more floor area Smaller footprint, uses height
Organisation Baskets on top, items stacked below Shelves and drawers, easy to see everything
Defrosting Usually manual defrost Frost-free models are common
Cold retention Cold air stays in when the lid opens Some cold air spills out when the door opens
Bulky items Great for large or awkward items Better for smaller, everyday items

The case for a chest freezer

Chest freezers are simple, roomy and good at holding cold because cold air sinks and stays in when you lift the lid. They suit:

  • Storing bulk meat, fish and large items such as whole turkeys.
  • Garages and laundries with plenty of floor space.
  • Households that don't need to access the freezer many times a day.

The main downsides are organisation and bending. Items at the bottom can be hard to reach and easy to forget. Using baskets, labelled bags and a simple list on the lid helps a lot. Most chest freezers also need manual defrosting when ice builds up.

The case for an upright freezer

Upright freezers look and work like a fridge, with shelves or drawers that make it easy to find things. They suit:

  • Kitchens, laundries and smaller spaces where floor area is limited.
  • Households that use the freezer every day.
  • People who prefer not to bend into a deep chest.

Many upright freezers are frost-free, which means no manual defrosting. Some models can also switch between fridge and freezer modes, which is handy for entertaining or seasonal needs. A matching upright fridge and freezer can sit side by side to create a large, flexible pair.

Capacity: how much do you need?

Freezer capacity is measured in litres. As a rough guide:

  • Around 100 to 150L: A small top-up freezer for couples or apartments.
  • Around 150 to 250L: A common size for families who buy in bulk or batch-cook.
  • 250L and above: Large families, hunters and fishers, or those who keep a lot of frozen produce.

Think about how full you'll keep it. A freezer that's mostly full works efficiently, while a very large, half-empty freezer uses energy to cool empty space.

Running costs and energy rating

Check the Energy Rating label, which shows a star rating and an estimated annual energy use in kWh. Comparing the kWh figure between models of similar size is the most useful way to compare running costs. Chest freezers have traditionally been efficient because they hold cold air well, but modern upright models can also perform well. Your own costs depend on your electricity tariff and how you use the freezer.

Where to put your freezer

Many second freezers live in the garage or laundry. Before you choose a spot, check:

  • Temperature range: Freezers are designed to work within a particular ambient temperature range, often shown as a climate class. Hot garages in summer and cold ones in winter can affect performance, so check the manufacturer's guidance.
  • Ventilation: Leave space around the freezer as stated in the manual.
  • Floor and access: Make sure the floor is level and the door or lid can open fully.
  • Power: Plug directly into a wall power point where possible, rather than a power board or extension lead.

Tips for an organised freezer

  1. Freeze food flat in bags so it stacks neatly and thaws faster.
  2. Label everything with contents and the date.
  3. Use baskets or tubs to group meat, vegetables and prepared meals.
  4. Keep a running list on the door or your phone.
  5. Rotate stock so older items are used first.

Good containers and a vacuum sealer help prevent freezer burn on meat and fish. Browse our food storage containers for stackable options.

What about a fridge-freezer upgrade instead?

If you mostly need a bit more freezer space, a larger fridge with a bigger freezer section may be enough. Our fridge buying guide explains top mount, bottom mount, French door and side-by-side layouts. For drinks overflow, a bar fridge is another option.

How to defrost a chest freezer

Manual-defrost freezers need defrosting when ice builds up, which reduces space and efficiency. Choose a cool day, move food into eskies or coolers with ice packs, switch off and unplug the freezer, and leave the lid open with towels around the base. Many chest freezers have a drain plug to make it easier. Never chip ice away with sharp tools, as this can damage the walls. Once dry, switch it back on and let it reach temperature before restocking. Our esky and cooler buying guide can help if you need somewhere to keep food cold.

Which freezer suits you?

Choose a chest freezer if you have floor space, buy in bulk, store large items, and don't mind defrosting occasionally.

Choose an upright freezer if you want easy organisation, a smaller footprint, frost-free convenience and daily access.

Freezer brands to compare

Our freezer range includes upright and chest freezers from Haier, Hisense, Kogan, Liebherr, Mykin and Westinghouse. Browse our wider fridges and freezers collection and our fridge range if you're comparing combinations. You can see every brand we stock on our brands page.

Related guides: Fridge Buying Guide, Bar Fridge Buying Guide, Esky and Cooler Buying Guide, Kitchen Storage.

Frequently asked questions

Is a chest or upright freezer more efficient?

Chest freezers hold cold air well when opened, but efficiency varies by model. Compare the annual kWh figure on the Energy Rating label for models of similar size.

Can I keep a freezer in the garage?

Often, yes, but check the model's climate class or operating temperature range, as very hot or cold garages can affect performance.

Do upright freezers need defrosting?

Frost-free upright freezers don't need manual defrosting. Manual-defrost models will need defrosting when ice builds up.

What size freezer do I need?

Many families find 150 to 250 litres works well for a second freezer. Choose larger if you buy in bulk or store game or fish.

Keep reading

Yoga Mat Buying Guide: Thickness, Grip and Material Tool Box Buying Guide: Chests, Cases and Trolleys Toaster and Sandwich Press Guide: Which Suits Your Kitchen?